Add a meta-reward card
I had posted in the Gameplay Advice column, asking for feedback on card mechanic where you reward players with a Meta-Wealth asset card, to reward them for posts that are extraordinary contributions to the story.
Several RPG systems have a way of challenging the players this way - Exalted potentially rewards players with experience and more dice vs. a roll for example.
For Storium, the player can later use that card during a post to have their character find/purchase/upgrade something amazing for their character.
Narrators can hand out asset cards to players for in-game or out-of-game achievements that can be used later on in the story.