David Reed
My feedback
13 results found
-
31 votes
Adminehardee
(Admin, Storium)
responded
The Activity Summary now lists how many cards each player has played in a given scene and how far along each challenge is and how it is trending (Weak/Strong/Neutral).
An error occurred while saving the comment -
15 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
2 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
63 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
31 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
37 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
369 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
90 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
202 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
950 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
244 votesDavid Reed
supported this idea
·
-
496 votes
We’re going to experiment with this idea during Gamma, along with some related concepts. Thanks for the feedback!
David Reed
supported this idea
·
-
26 votes
Thanks very much for that thoughtful feedback. This is one of the key mechanisms we are evaluating in this playtest, so it’s great to hear what you think about it.
The idea behind this mechanism is the “winner gets to narrate” model encourages people to play more cards sooner and make moves faster, so as to win control more often. Essentially, it’s a carrot to motivate people to “play harder”. And since playing your cards gets you closer to getting new cards, it is always a good thing to do it, even when you don’t end up winning the challenge.
Now, whether or not this is all actually true — and effective — remains to be seen. We’re keeping a close eye on it and will keep your feedback in mind for sure! Stay tuned…
An error occurred while saving the comment David Reed
commented
Voting with cards toward challenge outcome seems to be neutered by giving narration of the challenge completion to the player who contributed last... Reverse chicken will always be the result. Consider giving completion credit to the character who invested most heavily in the outcome.
David Reed
supported this idea
·
In addition to allowing the cast to float the way Commentary does, please add a 3-box indicator to the right of each Cast card indicating the kind of card(s) that each has played so far in the scene. They're only allowed 3 anyway, so showing empty boxes or the icons for each type of card would be grand!